Evaluation Supplier Checklist Template

by Rajeshwari Kumar


An Evaluation Supplier Checklist template is a specialized tool designed to assess and evaluate IT suppliers' performance within an organization's governance framework. This template ensures that IT suppliers adhere to the organisation's governance policies and standards. It provides a structured approach to measure various aspects of the supplier's performance, such as compliance with IT policies, security measures, service level agreements, and overall alignment with the organization's IT strategy. The checklist is instrumental in maintaining a robust and secure IT environment and managing risks associated with third-party IT service providers. This template allows organisations to effectively monitor and manage their IT supplier relationships, fostering a culture of accountability, transparency, and continuous improvement in their IT procurement processes

evaluation supplier checklist

Importance Of Having An Evaluation Supplier Checklist Template

The Evaluation Supplier Checklist template holds significant importance for businesses in managing their supplier relationships and ensuring the overall effectiveness of their supply chain. It is an indispensable tool for businesses looking to maintain a robust and reliable supply chain. It helps in managing risks, optimizing costs, ensuring compliance, and fostering collaborative relationships with suppliers, ultimately contributing to the overall success of the organization. It promotes fairness, objectivity, and transparency in supplier evaluations, ultimately benefiting the overall performance and success of the organization.
In an ever-changing business landscape, it provides a beacon of objectivity, allowing for fair and standardized evaluations.

This fosters transparency in supplier relationships and mitigates the risk of subjective assessments or potential biases. Furthermore, the template facilitates data-driven decision-making by quantifying supplier performance across various critical metrics. This empowers organizations to make informed choices regarding supplier selection, retention, and improvement. Additionally, it serves as a crucial tool for identifying areas of improvement and collaboration, driving continuous enhancement in supplier operations.

Who Uses The Evaluation Supplier Checklist Template?

Here are the key parties who commonly utilize the IT Governance Evaluation:

  • Supplier Checklist: Chief Information Officer (CIO): The CIO often oversees IT governance initiatives and uses the checklist to ensure that IT suppliers align with the organization's IT strategy, policies, and governance standards.
  • IT Governance Managers: Professionals responsible for IT governance practices use the checklist to evaluate supplier adherence to IT policies, standards, and compliance requirements.
  • Procurement and Vendor Management Teams: These Vendor Management teams use the checklist to assess and monitor IT supplier performance, contractual compliance and alignment with IT governance principles.
  • Chief Information Security Officer (CISO): The CISO focuses on IT security and uses the checklist to evaluate IT suppliers' security measures, data protection practices, and compliance with security policies and regulations.
  • Compliance Officers: These professionals ensure that IT suppliers adhere to legal and regulatory requirements. They use the checklist to verify compliance and address any compliance issues.
  • IT Auditors: Auditors may use the checklist during IT supplier audits to assess the supplier's adherence to governance and compliance standards.
  • IT Project Managers: When IT projects involve third-party suppliers, project managers use the checklist to evaluate supplier performance, especially regarding project delivery and compliance with project requirements.
  • IT Quality Assurance Teams: These teams assess the quality of IT products or services delivered by suppliers, using the checklist to maintain and enhance product or service quality.
  • Risk Management Teams: Teams responsible for IT risk management use the checklist to identify and mitigate risks associated with IT suppliers and ensure that supplier relationships align with risk management strategies.
  • IT Compliance and Governance Committees: These committees, if present, may use the checklist to assess and report on IT supplier compliance and governance performance to the organization's leadership.
  • IT Compliance and Governance Officers: Officers responsible for IT compliance and governance initiatives use the checklist to track and improve IT supplier adherence to governance standards.

Steps To Create Evaluation Supplier Checklist Template

Here's a step-by-step guide:

1. Define Objectives and Criteria: Determine the primary objectives of the evaluation (e.g., quality assessment, on-time delivery, compliance). Identify specific criteria that will be used to evaluate suppliers within each objective.

2. Evaluation field: It ensures that evaluations are consistent, transparent, and based on defined criteria, ultimately helping to make informed decisions about supplier relationships.

3. Person responsible: Specifying the person or team responsible for the evaluation is essential. This ensures accountability and clarity in the evaluation process.

4. Ratings: Ratings in an Evaluation Supplier Checklist template are numerical or descriptive scores assigned to specific criteria or categories to assess a supplier's performance. These ratings provide a quantifiable measure of how well a supplier meets the predefined standards or expectations.

5. Evaluation Period: Add a section to specify the evaluation period (e.g., monthly, quarterly, annually).

6. Comments and Notes Section: Allocate space for specific comments or notes regarding the supplier's performance in each category.

7. Action Plan Section: Provide space to identify actions to be taken based on the supplier's performance evaluation (e.g., corrective actions, improvement plans).

8. Follow-up and Monitoring: Include a section to specify the timeline for follow-up evaluations and how improvements will be tracked and monitored.

9. Provide Guidance and Training: If necessary, provide guidance or training to individuals responsible for using the template, ensuring they accurately fill it out.

10. Periodic Review and Update: Regularly review and update the template to reflect changing evaluation criteria, industry standards, or business requirements.

Evaluation supplier checklist

Maintaining And Updating The Evaluation Supplier Checklist Template

Steps to Maintain and Update the Checklist:

1. Regular Review: Set a schedule for regular reviews of the template. This could be monthly, quarterly, or annually, depending on your organization's needs.

2. Feedback Collection: Gather feedback from the individuals involved in the supplier evaluation process. This could include procurement teams, quality control personnel, and other relevant stakeholders.

3. Add or Modify Categories: Consider if additional categories should be included based on evolving business needs. For example, add a category for sustainability or ethical considerations.

4. Review Scoring System: Assess whether the scoring system is still appropriate. Adjust the rating scales or labels to reflect performance levels better if necessary.

5. Review Action Plan Section: Check if the action plan section is still effective in capturing corrective actions and improvement plans. Update it as needed to make sure it aligns with current practices.


By providing a structured framework for assessing supplier performance, this template enables organizations to uphold quality standards, mitigate risks, and drive continuous improvement within the supply chain. the template promotes accountability and transparency by clearly designating responsibilities for evaluation and providing a standardized approach. It facilitates open communication with suppliers, fostering collaborative efforts towards shared goals. The Evaluation Supplier Checklist template should evolve as industries and business landscapes evolve. Regular reviews and updates ensure that it remains aligned with current objectives and industry standards, ultimately enhancing its effectiveness in supplier assessment.